With the 24 team CFP on the horizon, we are should be standing at the edge of a new era in college football. Instead, we're still forcing the sport to limp along with a bunch of desperation deals holding things together.
Here is my proposal for how to restructure college football.
- Separate football from other sports. Conference affiliation in one does not necessarily carry over to them all.
- Fully separate Division I into three subdivisions - the Power teams, the mid-majors, and FCS.
- Consolidate the power teams into two large conferences, of 24-36 teams each.
- Pair up the power conferences with a mid-major counterpart to allow for relegation.
Conferences
For the sake of argument, the two conferences would be the SEC and Big Ten. The ACC and Big 12 would either dissolve, merge with one of the two, or only exist in non-football sports.
Bring back divisions within each conference, and it's going to be more than 2 per conference. This would restore many regional rivalries. It would also cut down on some of the unnecessary travel with teams going from coast to coast multiple times during a season.
The divisions will be small enough where a round robin schedule within the division is possible every season. This allows for proper tiebreakers that are determined on the field. Also, as division champions progress, then we can have full divisional representation. Every team in the division had a chance to play the eventual division winner.
If regular rivals end up in opposite conferences, then provisions should be made to maintain that rivalry game as a non-conference game.
By separating the current FBS into two further subdivisions, the Power teams can play the mid-majors, and mid-majors can play FCS, but the Power teams will not be allowed to play FCS teams.
And of course, Notre Dame would have to join a conference if they want to be included or even have a schedule.
Playoffs
Each division winner would get an automatic berth. The conference championship games would be the semi-finals.
In my original idea, I envisioned an 8 team playoff with four division winners in each conference. But that was developed before the 12 or 24 team playoff was created. Either there would be more divisions, or the top two teams from each division make it into the playoffs, or wildcards are added.
The mid-majors would have an opportunity for their own playoff system as well.
Relegation
Here's a crazy idea - the bad Power teams get demoted and the good mid-majors get promoted. But the only way it will work is if the Power conferences are paired with a mid-major conference and there is some sort of revenue sharing. Each school needs to maintain a certain level of certainty when it comes to their budget, so the conferences need to be aligned in some way, even if the mid-major conferences are subsidiaries of the Power conferences.
No comments:
Post a Comment